Paradise Pizza - Cape Coral

Reviews

• Richard H.

  star star star star star 13 June 2026

  Paradise Pizza, Lafayette St. Cape Coral,Fl.,Here is my 2 cents on the food. Pizza is a personal matter. So this is my best in the Cape.
  
  They give you lots of mushrooms, cover the pie with meat and the sauce is perfectly balance.
  
  All other place fail in these requirements
  
  I love the pie..

• Elke W.

  star star star star star 11 June 2026

  We love Paradise Pizza!!!
  This is the best Pizza in town. They never disappointed.
  Good quality, reasonable price and friendly staff.  
  Always a good experience.

• Jeff R.

  star star star star_border star_border 29 May 2026

  REVIEW ON PIZZA ONLY. This is a difficult review to write and this is why, I always order to go or delivery and I always order pasta dinners. The Chicken Cutlet and Veal Cutlet Parmesan ones are our favorite and they are awesome!! Recently I was picking up some food and my mouth was watering watching the countless pizzas coming in and out of the oven!! So yesterday my family was in a mood for PIZZA so I decided to call in a pizza order for pickup. Simple pizza, Hal sausage and half plain cheese. So here's my dilemma, the pizza itself tasted great however the crust was terrible. Maybe it was because the pizza had too much cheese but the crust was way too thin to the point of it being a floppy, cheesy mess. Couldn't pick up a slice and hold it in my hand to eat it!! Now I'll be the first one to tell you that pizza is best eaten at the restaurant you buy it from because once you put it in a box it'll get soggy. But this was different, I really think it was soggy when it came out the oven. It was literally paper thin!! Needless to say I'll stick with the pasta dishes and avoid the pizzas in the future.
  
  PS. They use a machine to flatten their dough so they either need to adjust this machine or the amount of dough used or both.

• Brittany B.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 23 May 2026

  Ordered a pizza at big storm brewery because they have a menu attached to their drink menu, starving I called at 3 and was done in less than 2 minutes, they said they'd walk it over and should be here in 20 minutes- it took me 45 minutes to call and they said it was on its way and another 10 minutes to send my husband across the street when finally some guy drove the pizza across the street my husband watched. No apologies or excuses... I ordered a large it wasn't more then 13 inches and it was hardly still hot and not cut completely. Very annoying. Lazy. Better customer service anywhere and Costco's pizza makes there seem like prevalence oven doll pizza. Obviously disappointed.

• Frankie K.

  star star star star star 22 May 2026

  We have got carry out pizza from here for years and it's always great!.... Our neighbors had never wanted there so we all went and let me tell you the rest of the menu is equally fantastic.
  Our server this evening was outstanding and the food was amazing.